Collapse- NORTH TOWER CAMERA ANGLES
WTC North Tower Collapse/Demolition Video Collection |
|---|
| - HD playlist ::: select high quality footage from 10:28 am on 9/11 - |
Please send additional North Tower "collapse" video & repeat airtime info to matt@911conspiracytv.
CollapseVideos - COLLECTION & DATABASE
AS IT HAPPENED ::: ANGLES SEEN ON TV NEWS AT 10:28 |
1. |
ABC NewsCopter7 YouTube or TV archive |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE Oct. 2010: Quality raw video has been found in the NIST Cumulus Video Database. NOTE: All entries on this webpage that are included in the NIST Cumulus database (as released by FOIA) will have the corresponding Cumulus file(s) named at the bottom of the entry (copied and pasted, minus the .avi file extension). |
2. |
CBS2 (WCBS) View 1: GM Building YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
New York local Channel 2 was running their GM Building camera, where The Early Show was/is produced. A recording has been available thanks to the Dr. Ebbetts DVD collection "September 11th As It Happened" (link 2 above). See one replay in the TV archive: CBS9 at 10:48 am (better quality link 1 above).
|
3. |
CBS2 (WCBS) View 2: Chopper2 TV archive or YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
CBS9 Washington aired the first few seconds in a small, split window, then put the LIVE destruction on full screen. On CBS2 (WCBS) only the falling "spire" of remaining core columns was seen. FOX News aired the 2nd half of the shot LIVE. See it also in the TV archive 9/11 at 5:01 pm on CBS9 Washington or in higher quality on FOX5 Washington at 10:42 am. |
4. |
CNBC - NBC River Shot, West YouTube 1, 2, 3, & 4 |
|---|---|
|
"There you see the building imploding.... Do you see what's happening? ... This is clearly-- the way the structure is collapsing.... This was the result of something that was planned. It's not accidental that the first tower just happened to collapse and then the second tower just happened to collapse in exactly the same way. How they accomplished this we don't know. But clearly this is what they wanted to accomplish." CNBC News anchor, 10:30 am
UPDATE Oct. 2010: Thanks to new archive TV from CNBC, this angle has been moved to the LIVE category. See a more organized playlist here at the 911conspiracy.tv NBC archive. |
5. |
CNN View 1: Roof Cam YouTube 1, 2, & TV archive |
|---|---|
|
CNN was using WNYW Chopper5 feed for the first two seconds of the "collapse." The shot then faded to this CNN camera at 5 Penn Plaza (their New York headquarters, with 2 or 3 cameras - see below), the view zoomed closest. Download the LIVE mpeg2. In the strange case of the South Tower footage - which missed it LIVE but did in fact capture it - the station didn't broadcast it until the middle of the night. |
6. |
CNN View 2: 5 Penn Plaza Wide Shot YouTube, or TV archive |
|---|---|
|
Download continuous replay in high quality (69.2MB avi with WTC 2 airing). CNN had their stationary camera at 5 Penn Plaza (their New York headquarters) up and running early that morning. But no video of the 1st plane surfaced. See a clip from this news compilation from 8:00 am on the Ebbetts DVD "As It Happened." |
ABOUT THIS LIST: Only views showing the tower descending for at least two seconds will be listed, with the exception of Jules Naudet's shot from the famous documentary "9/11." For example, the WNYW View 2: CBS "Blue Angle" aired only the last seconds of the building core "spire" falling. That still counts as a LIVE view. |
7. |
MSNBC - Chopper4 YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
This angle was seen for the first one second of the WTC 1 event on NY Channel 4. It was LIVE on MSNBC for the last seconds of the disaster, between the [FOX LIVE] NBC West St. view and the NBC GE Building cam, the latter of which only showed dust. Throughout the day, the NBC network broadcast bits of the shot, which I had to piece together to create a complete version (link 3 above [UPDATE: Quality recording newly available Oct. 2010. Link to come.]). |
8. |
MSNBC West View YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
"9/11 Television 1 of 12" was uploaded by MSTS1. The Boston VHS tape is important not because of this footage, but because only MSNBC used the FAA-approved software called Flight Explorer online, displaying the constantly-updated information from the skies on air LIVE before 10:28 am... AND this industry standard application showed UA Flight 175 - alleged to have hit the South Tower at 9:02:54 am - IN THE AIR, STILL! Ongoing research by Seatnineb looks at this in depth. |
9. |
NBC4 NY - WNBC from SoHo YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
WNBC's Joe Avellar broadcast LIVE minutes before the event, interviewing WTC survivors. The camera angle is seen again in that linked clip at 6:12 vrt, for a few seconds. His camera showed us the devastating action LIVE while reports came from the studio. |
10. |
NBC, FOX & ITV - WNBC West St. #1 YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Hear audio of the event. Behind the voices it's a muffled roar. NBC's Walter Perez was nearby, but this seems to be Pat Dawson's crew, who was set up to the left of Perez, across the street. Both had the white pedestrian bridge in view (see Google map). Also, MSNBC cut to Perez seconds after the disaster. Only recently has the NBC network coverage (and raw video) become available. The more familiar D.C. archive was running local coverage at the time. |
11. |
New York 1 (NY1) Empire State Bldg. YouTube |
|---|---|
|
The video can be seen, along with many other 9/11 clips, at the NY1 website. The camera is located on the Empire State Building near the 80th floor, very near the WB11 (WPIX) Metrocam that shared its view with WNYW, WABC, and more. NY1 didn't share. |
12. |
WB11 Chopper Air11 (WPIX-TV) YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Rare west side angle, a wide shot in comparison with the nearby WNYW FOX Chopper5 (see below). Air11 pilot: Ray Rivera. Reporter: Melinda Murphy (won an Emmy for breaking news 9/11). Camera: Chet Wilson and Brenda Banon (training as photographer). The LIVE WB11 footage features shots from both Chopper 11 - aka "Air11" - and WCBS Chopper2. The WB11 Empire State Building camera also captured the action, but only broadcast LIVE for a moment-- as the dust cloud rose. See details below under Network Views.
|
13. |
WNYW View 1: Chopper5 Youtube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Chopper5 missed the South Tower "collapse," but not the 2nd plane impact. Reporter/camera operator Kai Simonsen was ready for the 2nd demolition. Much of America was expecting it. After all, the towers were "twins." |
14. |
WNYW View 2: CBS Blue Angle YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE: With NIST FOIA 911datasets.org release 27, 42A0239 - G26D114 (clip), we can see the initiation full screen. |
15. |
WNYW View 3 (KTTV) Dick Oliver YouTube 1, 2, 3,& 4 |
|---|---|
|
This shot was only broadcast LIVE on WNYW's sister station in Los Angeles, KTTV FOX Channel 11 (link 1 above, final seconds only). Veteran reporter Dick Oliver and his cameraman were set up in front of the car wash at 124 Ave of the Americas, since before the 1st collapse. The camera shakes like in the non-TV "amateur" Sauret footage, but both occurences appear to be the fault of the camera operator. |
NETWORK VIEWS ::: NEWS CAMERAS, REPLAYS |
16. |
ABC7 (WABC) Reporter Jim Hoffer (partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Audio of the event is included, but not initiation. John Chow operated the camera, according to Hoffer in the broadcast excerpt (link 2 above at 5:24 - download avi). The clip aired nationwide at 11:45 am, for example. The horrible action is obscured by the pedestrian bridge crossing West Street to the high school. See the Jim Hoffer report on abclocal.go.com. |
17. |
ABC7 (WABC) Reporter Joe Torres YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Cameraman Glen Mayrose stands beside Joe in one report describing the earthquake rumbling below as the South Tower began to come down. The North Tower footage aired nationwide 9/11 on ABC at 7:06 pm, for example. Notably, a Port Authority engineer was being interviewed, talking about the strength and stability of the towers. Also see the Torres report on abclocal.go.com. |
18. |
ABC7 (WABC) Reporter Michelle Charlesworth YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Replayed many times across networks. Aired nationwide at 11:42 am, for example. Shot from the West Side Highway just north of Canal St, according to Michelle minutes before the South Tower demolition on WABC. She and her crew hadn't moved since then. |
19. |
ABC7 Reporter M. Charlesworth Alt. Zoom (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Features a spectacular view of the "spire" of core columns before it fell straight down. (See also non-TV amateurs Veoh Anon. & NY Center of the World, for example.). This camera was a few feet to the right and behind the perspective seen on TV repeatedly (listed above). This shot aired 9/11 at 11:39 and 11:58 pm somewhere (not Eastern Standard Time in NY, and not in the AM -- I've checked) on ABC, according to this clip from femr2 and this one from Xenomorph911WTC. Other clips available with this time stamp have come from the Nashville, Tennessee Vanderbilt University Television News Archive, which rents tapes for $200.00US. |
20. |
ABC7 (WABC) Reporter Nina Pineda (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
The footage aired 9/11 on ABC at 12:42 pm and at 7:10 pm. A female with an ABC microphone says that the second building has just come down. The Woolworth Building obscures the view, after the automatic light meter in the camera adjusts to the brightness of the sky. |
21. |
ABC7 (WABC) Reporter N.J. Burkett Video 1, 2, 3, & 4 |
|---|---|
|
See Burkett's report on abclocal.go.com. Marty Glembotzky was the camera operator (see In Memoriam: New York City 9/11/01..." (HBO, 2002) at 27:30 vrt). The scene begins with NYPD telling N.J. that the North Tower is leaning. That is why they were pulling people out of the area, N.J. learns... 20 seconds beforehand. This went out over NYPD radio at about 10:20 am (see NISTNCSTAR 1-8, p. 91/294), but due to the lack of FDNY radio interoperability, firefighters didn't get the advance knowledge. The fire dept. had the same radios that malfunctioned during the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. When replaced in a $14 million no-bid contract by Motorola (Feb. 2001), the new radios failed. The new radios had to be taken out of service in March... and replaced. Was this part of the conspiracy, to ensure death of American heroes? |
22. |
ABC - West St. Bridge: Spire, Dust YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE: Short clip found in the TV archive on GLVSN at 10:47 pm. Also see some Japanese news excerpts here, recently matched with this video and merged with a duplicate in this list (thanks, MrKoenig.) ABC network airings have not been found. |
23. |
AP/APTN Below North 1 Youtube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
This clip aired 9/11 at an unknown time on WNYW FOX5 (full broadcast at 9/11 TV archive 2, see"afternoon" news pt. 2). Available for viewing on the AP Archive website (or link 2 above), with a source listed as either APTN (AP Television News) or ABC (in part 11 and 13). Also the order of listed sources (or rights management) matches the order in which they appeared. |
24. |
AP/APTN Below North 2 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Unaired? After the zoom in, it looks very similar to the shot listed above. Unfortunately, the AP Archive files are not of the best quality. The mpeg2 clips look washed out and altered, in addition to the AP stamp, run time box, and story number box. Find download link in YouTube description, with more footage including the WTC7 demolition. |
25. |
BBC Correspondent Steve Evans YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Aired at 3:34 and again at 3:38 pm on 9/11, eastern standard time. Moments before the event, Steve describes a big explosion low in one of the towers (in 3:38 airing). He had no idea what could have caused that. To investigate this claim further, see the WTC demolitions playlists. |
26. |
BBC Motion Gallery YouTube 1 & 2 (extended) |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE Oct. 2010: Extended beginning found thanks to the NIST FOIA (link 2 above. file name below.) The initiation is missed, but the action slicing the west side faster than freefall is captured with a 2x zoom lens extender removed just before the BBC Motion Gallery version starts! |
27. |
CBS on West Side Hwy. YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
High quality versions now available thanks to the International Center for 9/11 Studies NIST FOIA, released in torrent form at 911datasets.org. Watch also in "Ground Zero Underworld," (UK Ch.4, 2007) more than once. The media had lined up on West St./the West Side Highway (you will notice). Byron Pitts presented the summary for CBS Evening News, during which this particular shot was the one used to show the North Tower event. Watch at the TV archive site and notice the edit. The 4:59 pm airing with an extra second reveals the zipper of explosions rapidly moving down the west face. (See "Acceleration + Serendipity" by DavidChandler911.) |
28. |
CBS Mark LaGanga YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Previously "Dust Cloud Closeup." UPDATE: Camera operator Mark LaGanga was named in the NIST FOIA, release 25, folder 42A0120 - G25D31 (Watch in full now), which features extended tape from CBS going into WTC Building 7 between collapses. As WTC 1 "falls" LaGanga doesn't budge as people run for their lives! Somebody is knocked to the ground by the force of the wind, just before pebbles hit the camera lens and all becomes black. The camera lens is too dusty to see detail of the "collapse" initiation. |
29. |
CNBC West St. (New Sept. 2010) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE Sept. 2010: New archive TV from CNBC is available. See a more organized playlist here at the 911conspiracy.tv NBC archive. However, I haven't found the clip air time yet-- only the two sources above. I think this is this a network camera because 1. The media was lined up on West St. and 2. CNBC seemed to air only network shots. |
30. |
FNN Japan, West Side Hwy. YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Partial view of the descent. One of many many views from the West Side Highway (West St.), including another Japanese camera (assumed) next on this list. This one gives us a look at a news cameraman in the foreground who turns and begins to run! See that camera's view (ITN Clip 77 of 82, below). |
31. |
FNN Japanese Reporter on Rooftop YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Download avi including 2 above FNN shots and other 9/11 footage from Japan, including shots with audio rarely seen. I can't be sure the network is FNN, but the title of the download file suggests it is. |
32. |
FOX News Building Roof - Verizon View YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
See "FOX Report" anchor Shepard Smith on the roof of the FOX News building at 1211 Avenue of the Americas ... the camera location ... as he talks to witnesses, one of whom describes explosion sounds that traveled a great distance. The shot aired, for example, at 9:28 pm on 9/11. |
33. |
FOX News West Side Hwy. YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Copyright FOX News at the itnsource.com stock footage site, clip 12 of 26. I haven't found it in the TV archive at archive.org. Only recently on September 11, 2009 was it seen on FOX News in "9/11: Timeline of Terror." |
34. |
GLVSN 9/12 at 3:11 P.M. YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Blanca Rosa Vilchez and camera operator Miguel M. Pinzon were very close to the scene during the WTC 2 collapse. The footage playing right after that must be their WTC 1 shot from further back on West Street. Watch at the TV archive now, which only became available in late 2011. |
35. |
Inside_Edition YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Matt Meagher reports on the scene. Brad Waite, cameraman ("Waite's camera work earned him and his crew the only national Emmy nomination given that year to photography.") This rare news clip is worth watching just to see yet another witness to the explosion in the lobby just before the first plane hit. Learn all about that event not properly documented by NIST at the Loose Change forum. |
36. |
ITN West Side Hwy. YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Seen internationally, courtesy of ITN/Reuters. On BBC Newsnight (link 3 above) the shot comes after NBC West St. (FOX LIVE) view. In the itnsource.com stock footage compilation it is clip 77 of 82. I haven't found it in the TV archive at archive.org. |
37. |
NBC Northwest Distant Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
Aired on NBC4 Washington on 9/11 at 12:41 pm. While this isn't confirmed as a "network view," NBC was known for its "SkyCam network" of easily accessible cameras. See this image for example-- an angle without a matching video on record (no 2nd plane video, either - source). On March 8, 1996, WNBC unveiled the first-of-its-kind Skycam Network consisting of high resolution, remote controlled cameras perched at key points of interest across the Tri-State area. The Skycam Network is in operation 24 hours a day and features 24 cameras. The state-of-the-art Skycam Network is an investment in WNBC's overall coverage of the Tri-State area and is used in all local newscasts. Since its debut, the station has used the Skycam Network to highlight traffic situations; check on Newark, LaGuardia and Kennedy airports; present live pictures of developing weather situations; and, capture breaking news stories.... - http://www.telemundo47.com/station/1169359/detail.html |
38. |
NBC View 2: GE Building YouTube 1 & ... |
|---|---|
![]() |
The South Tower from this view aired LIVE and played much more often that day (on NBC4 Washington, at least). The camera was on top of the 70-story GE Building at 30 Rockefeller Center, which became an observation deck/tourist attraction - "Top of the Rock" - in 2005. The building is home to most of NBC's New York studios. |
39. |
NBC View 3: West Street HQ YouTube 1, 2, 3, 4... |
|---|---|
![]() |
Correction: This I thought to be Pat Dawson's crew, but the LIVE shot above has been proven to be. ... The HQ in the title stands for high quality. This video, as Achimspok notes, "helps to prove all theories." Downloadable HQ NBC archive clip as WTC1_NW_Corner.avi, with repeated zooms, thanks to Xenomorph911WTC. He also made an HD version, perhaps from the PBS documentary version (link 2 above). The clip appeared in the 2006 History doc "American Vesuvius," as seen on YouTube here with NBC replays (WTC compared to volcano). |
40. |
NBC with Woolworth Building YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Download mpeg2 with rare archive timestamp, or a HQ zoom repeat slow motion .avi (Thanks Xeno!). |
41. |
NHK Japan YouTube |
|---|---|
|
New Sept. 2011 with the release of the expanded 9/11 TV archive at archive.org, featuring broadcasts from around the world up through September 17th. New to this list Jan. 2012. During the initiation of collapse, the camera was zooming in on the antenna, shaking somewhat. Still it's powerful video. (Also notice the collapse was missed LIVE, as a clear, elevated north view turned to studio commentary for 2 minutes! No replay from that view, either.) |
42. |
New York 1 (NY1) West St. YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
The video can be seen, along with many other 9/11 clips, at the NY1 website. About one minute before the collapse, the reporter and camera can be seen in the 2008 History Channel program "102 Minutes That Changed America." |
43. |
PAX-TV (WNBC) West St. YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Update: Jeff Scarborough, WNBC camera operator. Full length aftermath features gunshots! Yes, gunshots... to break windows and escape the savage dust and debris clouds. Thanks to jonfromqueens for uploading this rare afternoon TV segment May 7, 2010 (link 2 above). It was first found in a bulk download with no audio and the "PAX" NBC logo (link dead). |
44. |
Thought Equity Unknown YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Could very well be the missing view from Walter Perez of WNBC. Watch him on NBC Channel 4 moments after the collapse, from very near another NBC crew (Pat Dawson), whose shot was aired LIVE and replayed often, unlike this rare clip. Here it is on the Thought Equity stock footage site. |
45. |
WCBS West St. Partial YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE: Moved/renamed from "Unknown West St. Partial" upon discovery in the WCBS Channel 2 broadcast at 4:44 p.m. and 5:13 p.m (thanks to user 911Clips). You'll notice that many others filmed the event from West St./West Side Hwy. This camera was also one of several to capture the south tower west side falling into the street from very close. |
46. |
West St. Unknown 1 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Very close to several news cameras. See FNN Japan West St. above and West St. Unknown 2, for example. It seems like there were more cameras on this street than there were people! |
47. |
West St. Unknown 2 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Very close to several news cameras. See FNN Japan West St. and West St. Unknown 1 above, for example. The source is unknown. Thanks 911allcausticcamera for uploading. |
48. |
WPIX (WB11) Metrocam YouTube 1, 2, 3, & 4 |
|---|---|
|
As seen from the Empire State Building... called Metrocam by the news presenters. This camera was shared by WABC and WNYW from the start of the day's coverage, but WB11 aired the 2nd plane impact from this angle LIVE. Side note: See the new WPIX 9/11 memorial page now. |
49. |
WPIX Reporter Jamie Colby (NEW Jan. 2011) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Aired on WB11 9/11/2001 at 7:50 P.M. (full broadcast here). Similar to APTN Below North 2. Source: the 2010 Int'l Center for 9/11 Studies NIST FOIA, 911datasets.org release 28 folder 42A0305-G28D10, WPIXCD7of7. Resized from the odd 352x480 original. |
AMATEURS, UNKNOWNS IN THE TV ARCHIVE, INCLUDING ALL 2001 TV |
50. |
BBC Demo Wave 9/13 at 4:42 PM YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Important North Tower demolition footage: see it in the TV archive now. Download the mpeg2 now. Also see it zoomed and stabilized, with download links at YT. |
51. |
BBC Explains Why (ABC/TLC) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Collapse explained on BBC at 1:43 pm AND at 2:10 pm AND at 3:08 pm on 9/11 in repeat airings. See it in the TV archive now. It's good for a laugh a quick explanation that the exterior columns supported most of the weight, so the buildings were done for... now here's Tom with the weather. Not exact words, but you get the idea. |
52. |
BBC NE View 9/12 at 1:03 am Watch |
|---|---|
|
Called "Rare collapse 37" by 911allcausticcamera at the link above. See it in the TV archive now. I've not come across the mpeg2 (high quality) clip. (Here is the list of 1GB mpeg2 TV archive timeslots I do have.) If anybody has it, please contact me. Thanks. ... See a similar view of the South Tower collapse, aired in Portugal. |
53. |
Craig Braden Angle 1 - FOX News YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
(See Craig Braden Angle 2 below under non-TV.) Aired on FOX 9/11 at 9:51 pm, with a shot of the 1st "collapse." Another appearance of this clip was in the History website clip "Collapse of the North Tower" at 3:45 of 4:27 (YT link 2 above). |
54. |
CBS 9/14 at 4:33 am Unknown YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE: Found with audio at the producers library stock footage website, with audio. Thanks 911allcausticcamera for uploading (YT link 2 above). |
55. |
CBS 9/14 at 11:20 am Unknown Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
Watch at the new TV archive site. The WTC 2 shot seen in the same clip is more interesting. The discussion during the clip concerns skyscraper integrity, but nothing specific to the towers. This particular angle is almost the same as killtheartist1 below, and similar to the above BBC NE View 9-12. |
56. |
Clifton Cloud YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Clifton captured the 2nd plane impact and both "collapses" with his videocamera. Also, untelevised amateur Devin Clark and TV amateur Chris Hopewell caught all 3 events. Network cameras that did that include the CBS "Blue Angle" view, CNN 5 Penn Plaza (one of 2 cameras), NBC GE Bldg. (leaning cam), WPIX Metrocam, and NY1 ESB cam. The footage linked above comes from an interview on NBC 9/12 at 11:50 am. |
57. |
Peter Damas YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE Jan 2012: Videographer first name found in a rare WCBS Channel 2 broadcast recording originally at the YouTube channel 911Clips. See also the NIST archive.org video repository where a download is available, or the FOIA Cumulus folder "WCBS NIST Dub #1_Damas home video." Peter captured the 2nd plane crash (explosion only) and both collapses. |
58. |
Lucia Davis YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Aired September 22, 2001 in "MSNBC Investigates: 24 Hours at Ground Zero" (link 2 above). Also included in the 2002 TLC program "World Trade Center: Anatomy of the Collapse." Davis is credited as working with BNN in the 2002 HBO program "In Memoriam: New York City 9/11/01." (see full docu. here) BNNtv more or less became CameraPlanet. |
59. |
Extra (WNBC) West YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE 2011: Moved from "CNN Extra" to "Extra." Newly available in extended length thanks to RTL. In Sept. 2010 it became available in hi res, extended length thanks to the NIST FOIA: watch now. And LISTEN (volume increased). Credited to WNBC in NIST volume 1-6. |
60. |
Dr. Mark Heath Youtube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Short HQ version on FOX5 Washington at 7:46 pm. Also see a CNN extended version with audio at 4:24 pm. Also, there's a darkened version on CBS9 Washington at 5:21 pm. Suspicious minds may think this has something to do with the apparent explosive flashes on the west face (Frame 1154 [or 2308 in doubled frame rate] of the NIST version, for example) .. flashes that are more likely attributable to camera tape static or glass shards reflecting light. |
61. |
Chris Hopewell, "Eyefull" (aka Tinacart/Naudet) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
"Eyefull, Inc." is credited at aparchive.com, video archive for Associated Press and AP Television News (APTN)... and ABC. See a screenshot of aparchive.com details, since navigating that site requires registering. The footage (a copy?) was acquired by the Library of Congress September 11 collection, and is credited/listed under "Film Makers." Quote: "World Trade Center Attack. Courtesy Chris Hopewell + Carol Wells, Eyefull Inc." |
62. |
NBC 9/11 2:59 PM American Flag (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
An American flag. I'm surprised this angle didn't get more attention... although the edit takes away from the shot. It may be a network camera. Also found as an mpeg1 with other news from 9/11... at archive.org in the impact collection, specifically in this video file. |
63. |
NBC Ch. 10 Philadelphia, WSW Low res only |
|---|---|
![]() |
A more complete version was made with joined clips from two segments found in rare news coverage posted by September11thArchive, who has unfortunately closed his/her YouTube account. |
64. |
Etienne Sauret YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Aired on CNN at an unknown time (see link 1). Professional quality. His shot features the earth apparently shaking ~10 seconds before the "collapse." Comparing other videos finds no verification of the phenomenon (see for instance Rick Siegel 911 Eyewitness Hoboken compared). Camera location at 145 Ave of the Americas was about 1.54km away, and considering the time it takes for seismic waves to travel ("surface waves" (?) being half as fast as primary waves, or sound waves... the speed of sound through granite is 5,000 m/s), the shake would have taken about a second to travel to Sauret's camera. |
65. |
SWM (FOX5 Atlanta 6:50 PM) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE: Moved from untelevised amateurs once found in the NIST FOIA release 27, folder 42A0215 - G26D75 (The FOX5 Atlanta report was replayed 9/12 morning - see 42A0221 - G26D89). More interesting than the footage is the opinion of Trade Center historian/author Eric Darton, who noted that the towers "sort of imploded." |
66. |
WCBS from Chinatown, Unknown (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Found on YouTube channel 911Clips during the Channel 2 broadcast at 10:21 p.m. "A rare shot from CBSNewYork.com," says prolific YouTube uploader IranContraScumDid911, who shared the video on Oct. 7, 2011 (YT link above). After searching that website I could find no coverage from 9/11, but perhaps it was a temporary feature during the recent 10th anniversary. |
67. |
WCBS from Queensboro Bridge Park (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Found on YouTube channel 911Clips during the Channel 2 broadcast at 10:48 p.m., minutes after a report that a truck full of explosives had been stopped... notice a banner reads "Explosives found under the GW Bridge," when reports only spoke of a van/truck stopped in Jersey. Watch compiled reports across networks. Was this the same van driven by the 5 "dancing Israelis?" |
AMATEURS NOT IN THE TV ARCHIVE |
68. |
Andrés Barrilá Youtube 1, 2 (HQ), & 3 |
|---|---|
|
One version uploaded by Barrilá aka inoutcut titled "9-11 TWIN TOWERS Original Video and Sound ANDRES BARRILA" (YouTube 1 above - low resolution), another titled "9/11 HQ 'TWIN TOWERS ANDRES BARRILA'.FROM THOMPSON & WATTS ST" (link 2 above, with another identical version at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HFHOolP5p1Q by his other account barrila9112001, but titled en Espanol.) Version 3 by Barrilá is in slow motion. FYI, you will find the South Tower clip under televised amateurs. Thanks, Andrés! |
69. |
bkaye YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
New Sept. 6, 2011 as posted by YouTuber/videographer bkaye who said: "This is footage I shot on 9/11/2001. It was from 14th Street and 6th Avenue.
Note about 3:49 seconds in, Bernard Goetz, who lives in the neighborhood." |
70. |
Bob and Bri - "What We Saw" Youtube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Uploaded to Revver 9/11/2006, with a suspicious edit during the plane impact. It could just be that the recording was stopped for a minute... bad timing... as with the South Tower's "collapse." BUT what about the edit during the North Tower demolition? Why? Then there's the fascinating comment (by Bri?) about the jetliner being a "military plane." Crazy day. |
71. |
Nick Buzzell (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
New Sept. 13, 2011 as posted by WagnerCollegeNYC, who said: "This short documentary, posted on our YouTube channel by permission, was produced by Buzzell from the video footage he shot that day from Harbor View Hall." That's in Staten Island. WTC2 falling was also captured partially... and set to ambient music for YT. |
72. |
Craig Braden Angle 2 YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
No version with the initiation is available. Newly found in the NIST Cumulus FOIA, yet not exclusive to that. See Craig Braden Angle 1 in TV amateur views above, although Craig isn't an amateur. He's a pro, but not a network camera (or cameras plural... I don't know how he operated two at the same time with adjustments being made to both simultaneously). See the two angles shot by Craig in his demo reel at 5:10... with many celebrities and world events. The video link above is from that, not NIST. |
ABOUT THIS LIST: The CameraPlanet Archive has collected 500 or so hours of 9/11 footage (says NY Times), but the Archive does not necessarily own the rights to all of it. A few of the camera angles titled "CameraPlanet..." below have been matched with a videographer's name. Still, the videos will appear in this list alphabetically under "C," to provide a consolidated collection of North Tower "collapse" videos from "the Archive." Note that televised amateur Lucia Davis is excuded from this portion of the list. |
73. |
CameraPlanet: Cynthia Malaran YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Shot from an East Village apartment. Cynthia's artistic WTC photos poster gives a beautiful, extended time lapse of the World Trade Center's life and disappearance. National Geographic (and CameraPlanet) featured her footage of the North Tower destruction in the bonus program "Witness 9/11," in the DVD documentary set titled "Inside 9/11" (2006). Cynthia nearly captured the 2nd plane impact on film, but was setting up her tripod. |
74. |
CameraPlanet - Driving Away YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
We hear the name Brian mentioned in the vehicle... and one Brian Tunney is on cameraplanet.com where we can read the camera owner's story: "... Rushed downtown from 30th Street to lower Manhattan (Church Street) while filming. Left the van on the street. Hopped out with the camera and went looking for Matt. Filmed first collapse. Found Matt running uptown. Hopped in van, passed camera to Matt, who filmed out the window while the second tower stood alone and then collapsed." The high quality link 2 above comes from the 9/11 Truth documentary/news & video footage compilation "9/11 Revisited: Were explosives used?" (2009). Find high quality downloads at archive.org. This particular clip is in version 2 of the film, at 19:57 vrt. |
75. |
CameraPlanet "HL" West Side Hwy YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Titled "hl_2nd_tower_coll_" with little effort for quality archiving. Several clips titled "HL..." appear in the CameraPlanetArchive YouTube channel, hiding the identity of the videographer. The full length documentary "7 Days in September" (no video link available?) provides the name Harry Lapham. See him in this brief interview clip, less than 20 seconds long like many of the videos posted by "the archive." |
76. |
CameraPlanet "Rare collapse 12" NE YouTube |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE: New, better quality version available at the 9/11 Memorial website. [Jan. 2012, dead link now] |
77. |
CameraPlanet "Shot of Tower 1... from east side" YouTube 1, 2, 3, & 4 (new) |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE: New extended version available at the 9/11 Memorial website [Jan. 2012 dead link but ripped as YT link 4 above] -- with audio, including a notable comment from a bystander: "That's a f__ing bomb." |
78. |
CameraPlanet - Suzanne Kaufman (partial) Source & YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Video owner's name found at thecameraplanetarchive.magnify.net/.... South Tower collapse was completely missed, while the second collapse only featured the spire falling behind WTC Building 7. The dust cloud starred in both shots of this 2-minute video. A shorter clip is also on the CameraPlanetArchive YouTube channel (YT link above). The footage was aired in the 2002 PBS/NOVA documentary "Why the Towers Fell" (at 43:15). |
79. |
CameraPlanet - Ted C. (West partial) YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Seen from Jersey City, the tower started to crumble before the camera was set up. Best version in Nat'l Geographic's "Inside 9/11" DVD bonus program (2006) "Witness 9/11," which was produced by CameraPlanet. See Ted discussing the day. Parts of the same interview are on the CameraPlanetArchive YouTube channel, most not much longer than 5 seconds long. |
80. |
CameraPlanet - West Wide Shot (partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE Sept. 2010: The videographer has put together a short documentary with narration: "THE VIEW FROM SUMMIT AVE- Never before seen 9/11 documentary footage." Additional footage before the South Tower event from this Jersey angle was included in "7 Days in September" (CameraPlanet, 2002) with narration by Rob Santana, the camera operator. It was his birthday. |
81. |
CameraPlanet - Women in Shock (partial) YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Named December 2011 after finding the February 2011 upload at http://thecameraplanetarchive.magnify.net/... (at 3:11 into video). Previous CameraPlanet compilations have not included the collapse sequence, only the women's reactions. However, the video is on the CameraPlanetArchive YouTube channel (YT link 1 above). |
82. |
Zabo Chabiland aka doodletv (East) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Uploaded to YouTube by doodletv May 23, 2007 with the following info: "911 From Dumbo beach under the Manhattan bridge." Original is 9:58 in duration. |
83. |
chlarkfan73 - Jersey City View Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
Handheld wide to medium shot. Uploaded to YouTube November 01, 2008 by chlarkfan73. Original title: "WTC 9.11 (Jersey City, NJ view)." Other Jersey views include Hoboken by Siegel (non-TV), Meridianmulti (non-TV)... |
84. |
Devin Clark YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
|
Originally found on Devin's website bodyatomic.com see archived videos page, where his 8 minute "What I Saw From My Window" is NOT available. (download .mov here) Devin's video is also "United Airlines Flight 175 Witness Reactions III" on the tinacart YouTube channel. UPDATE: Also see his collapse footage (both towers) in the highly recommended "Oil, Smoke, and Mirrors" (at vrt 29:20). |
85. |
Discovery Partial NE (New Sept. 2010) no link |
|---|---|
|
The rare clip is barely 2 seconds long, as found in the new documentary "After the Towers Fell" (at 1:15 in) which is not available at the 911conspiracy.tv mainstream documentaries page. Two other new 9/11 documentaries to add this year include Nat. Geo's "Giuliani's 9/11" (not added) and "Witness D.C. 9/11" (added). Others? |
86. |
Caroline Dries (NEW 2011) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Caroline's footage premiered on History's "102 Minutes that Changed America" in 2008, but only the plane crash explosion. |
87. |
Ilse Fernandez YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Titled "9.11 World Trade Center view from Thompson Street in NYC" -- uploaded by 'ilsefernandez' September 20, 2007 with 'more info' that reads, "9.11 view of the towers from thompson street right before they fall." The shot quickly zooms out to a medium-to-wide shot, pretty stable for a handheld. The core remnant collapse in last second fades out. Ilse's video also captured the South Tower demolition. |
88. |
FireLine Video YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE Oct. 2010: Renamed thanks to the NIST FOIA/Cumulus video database. More info on the videographers can be found in the WTC 2 webpage entry. Extended version found in 10 parts at globalimageworks.com, with audio of FDNY radio chatter. A similar view of the WTC 1 event is APTN Below North. |
89. |
German - Greenpoint, NYC (partial) Watch |
|---|---|
|
Only the spire is seen falling, but a new view. Thanks for pointing that one out, Prishep. Anybody else have a new view? Visit that link and post. |
90. |
Getty Images, Watertowers YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Found at the Getty Images archive films website and seen in HD (YT link above) during History Channel's 2008 "102 Minutes that Changed America." The distance makes it almost seem peaceful. It was used twice in the History Channel's "World Trade Center: Rise and Fall of an American Icon" (2002), as evidenced by NIST Cumulus file "Rise Fall Hist Part A Clip23." Also at Getty is the Onno de Jong shot. |
91. |
Richie Gibbs YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
New Sept. 10, 2011 as posted by YouTuber "richiegibbs," who said: "This is my footage from that day and beyond. At the end is footage of a Daniel Suhr memorial service. Daniel Suhr was the first nyc firefighter killed on 9-11-01. I'll always remember the look in the eyes of his father." The footage, shot from a rooftop in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, doesn't include the initiation. Same for WTC 2. |
92. |
Fred Hadley Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
Steady wide shot. Uploaded to YouTube September 10, 2008 by Queensdude. Original title: "World Trade Center 9/11 from Queens/Nassau Border." Description: "Possibly the most distant (16 mi.)video footage of the second jet hitting the South Tower and the collapse of the North Tower." Also find Fred's video on the makehistory.national911memorial.org website, with a current total of only 16 videos. FYI, there was a more distant view of the plane hitting: the "Earthstation" aircraft (unknown) was about 18 miles away. While most camera locations for the 2nd plane videos have been plotted, the South and especially North Tower videos remain mostly uncharted. |
93. |
Hallmark YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
One (the?) source is terrorize.dk. Seen in an unknown TLC program. Found also by femr2 and/or clauzii. These two researchers deserve much thanks for their hard work! More info? Contact matt@911conspiracytv. |
94. |
David Haverty (partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Posted Jan. 2011 on YouTube by "dvdvanity," who "was 2 blocks from the World Trade Center when we were attacked that day." Video was found by researcher 911allcausticcamera and listed as collapse 123. Low resolution with the tower obscured by buildings, the footage also includes chaotic running from the WTC 2 catastrophe. |
95. |
ilchaco YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Stable, extended length (9:11 - clever) wide shot. "Collapse" begins at 3:01. Uploaded to YouTube August 27, 2007 by ilchaco. Original title: "New 911 world trade center september 11 wtc ." The audio is an ambient music. |
96. |
jacob7207 - Brooklyn View 1 YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Handheld wide to medium shot. Uploaded to YouTube December 22, 2008 by videographer jacob7207. Original title: "911 Home Video Documentary, filmed from Ft. Greene Brooklyn, 2/3 ." Description: "I filmed and edited this. Sorry for the poor quality, it hasn't been easy putting this together." Rare Brooklyn view. |
97. |
Tim Jervis - North on West Side Google Video & YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Handheld wide shot, low resolution. Tim did put a good still from his video on his blog, though (or a photo). See http://timjervis.blogspot.com/2001/09/911.html |
98. |
jimnxsq - Brooklyn View 2 YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Handheld wide to medium shot. Uploaded to YouTube July 18, 2006 by jimnxsq. Original title: "9/11: As It Happened - from Brooklyn; The North Tower Falls." Brooklyn views are rare! Maybe that's due to poor quality angle, considering the smoke. |
99. |
johncira YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
New Sept. 8, 2011 as posted by YouTuber "johncira" who said: "When I stepped outside my apartment door and onto 6th Avenue, it seemed such a perfect day, nothing could go wrong." John chose a choice word to describe people's reactions that day: bewilderment. Although a quality shot, it's only 360p resolution (except where enhanced.) Unlike the north tower collapse, the WTC 2 shot wasn't fully captured due to early focus on the closer tower. |
100. |
Onno de Jong YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Still images from this video appear in NIST volume 1-6, for both the North and South Tower events. The video can be found at the Getty Images archive films website. It's a well-framed, stable shot. Find it in extended length with the South Tower demolition at link 2 above. The shot was used in the first 30 seconds of History Channel's "World Trade Center: Rise and Fall of an American Icon" (2002), link 3 above. This video is not to be confused with a nearby "Unknown NNE" shot below. |
101. |
Noah Klersfeld (East partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
"September 11th" was uploaded to YouTube Oct. 1, 2007 by talkingdoggirl and can be found as a .mov file at digitalmartin.com. The collage video features 2 (or more) videographers in Manhattan. One is Alfie Alvarado (see the South Tower collapse collection). Alfie isn't named, but the footage has been matched. The other videographer is named at the end of the 9:44 length video... Noah Klersfeld. We see a street sign "Catherine St." -- which places the camera about here. Thanks, Martin, for your efforts. |
102. |
Bruno_Levy (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Beginning of destruction is missed. Seen with "SY01" below, thanks to Dan Klein at bestshotfootage.com, who emailed me the video "LV01" upon request. So far I haven't found it elsewhere. |
103. |
Lkungfu (partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
New Sept. 2011 as posted by 911allcausticcamera, titled collapse 120. Originally posted by the apparent videographer on YT Jan. 2011. It's an incomplete shot in low resolution with the tower obscured by buildings. Also found on a low res flickr photostream. |
104. |
Meridianmulti (West partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
The videographer has expressed his unwillingness to create an unedited version of his video, which is a shame because in the South Tower portion, bold text with the incorrect time is emblazoned on the screen AND the descent is edited, clipped in the middle! It seems the WTC 1 initiation was missed. |
105. |
Merrill Lynch, AP (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Using the process of elimination, it can be discerned that AP credits Merrill Lynch in the title info at the beginning of the video "screener" file. The APTN and ABC clips come first, as listed in the titles. This view is not to be confused with the Moussaoui Trial Exhibit Clip 10. Both were shot from the unfinished Hudson River Greenway... this shot closer to the WTC and the river. |
106. |
Gabriella Messina, West Side Hwy (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
This comes from the 2002 HBO documentary "In Memoriam: New York City 9/11/01," which focuses on NYC Mayor Rudy Giuliani's experiences. The wonderful thing about the doc. is that the videographers are named! Locations are given as well. Watch that program and many more on the mainstream documentaries page here at 911conspiracy.tv. |
107. |
Metro Staff - Brooklyn View 3 (partial) Google video |
|---|---|
![]() |
This low res shot starts about 2 seconds after the initiation. Titled "Metro Staff watching WTC on 9/11," the description tells us: "This video was shoot on the roof of our office at 17 Menahan st. I remember looking at this, and screeming [sic]: OH My God! OH My God! The comments you hear on this video are from Marty W., who is filming, and tries to discribe [sic] what is happening..." |
108. |
Modern Marvels Demolition Episode (Partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Unknown amateur shot - plus Ground Zero testimony of red hot steel up to 2 weeks after the "collapses." Clip from Modern Marvels Demolition segment on WTC Ground Zero recovery. Project Superintendant Michael Casale of Mazzocchi Wrecking discusses "steel coming out red in certain areas for the first couple weeks, at least." Which opens the door to a flood of molten steel research: Molten Steel & Extreme Temperatures at WTC. |
109. |
Moussaoui Trial Exhibit P200015, Clip 10 YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
First, here is all you need to know about the Moussaoui case, including the obvious obstruction of the investigation pre-9/11 (and even after 9/11, until it was deemed acceptable for the FBI to get their search warrant). Moussaoui could have led to the other alleged hijackers and spoiled the cover for the entire black op. |
110. |
Moussaoui Trial Clip 11 & Penttbom FOIA YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
UPDATE August 2011: Available on the NIST website. Video online since May 4, 2006... according to United States District Court Eastern District of Virginia. Without knowledge of its use in this case, it was uploaded to YouTube November 07, 2008 by penttbom.com YouTuber bronco2121, who received 10 DVDs from the FBI on November 3rd, 2008. See penttbom.com for the story on Scott Bingham's FOIA request for 9/11 material. (No relation to Flight 93 passenger Mark Bingham, as far as I know.) Scott operates the website flight77.info, which tells more of the quest for the missing Pentagon plane impact videos. |
111. |
Jules Naudet, "9/11" YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Although the tower is in view for a moment during the initiation, the collapse is not seen. Still, this angle must be included here. Audio is preserved, assuming no artistic license or censorship has occurred (as with brother Gedeon's airplane impact shot, with missing frames). Notice the vacuum effect as the dust and paper is sucked up the street back toward Ground Zero! This phenomenon is investigated briefly by Achimspok in NORTH TOWER part2 - Ch18. |
112. |
Lance Nealy no link |
|---|---|
![]() |
New addition Nov. 2010 thanks to the work of 911allcausticcamera (Nevermind, the video was removed due to a copyright claim by Lance). The video was once found at nealy.net. The view is from Jersey City Heights. |
113. |
"New York: Center of the World" Zoom on Spire YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Partial view begins mid-collapse, same as at the Thought Equity stock footage site. The documentary is actually called "The Center of the World - New York: A Documentary Film." The 2003 PBS film tells the official fairy tale with tons of excellent footage (see it on 911conspiracy.tv now). Speaking during the clip is journalist William Langewiesche, author of American Ground: Unbuilding the World Trade Center (North Point Press, New York, 2002), which was the product of unique unrestricted access for the duration of the "cleanup" recovery effort. While it stuck to the official story of natural, gravity driven collapse, the book documented "the streams of molten metal that leaked from the hot cores and flowed down broken walls inside the foundation hole." (p. 32). The cores were steel, of course. Please see Molten Steel & Extreme Temperatures at WTC for collected testimony to this particular proof for controlled demolition. |
114. |
New York Times Online YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Original source: http://www.nytimes.com/library/national/091101manhattan-large.html. Naka Nathaniel plane impact edited out for YouTube clip linked above. South Tower demolition view from across East River. North Tower seen from distance through telephoto lens. |
NIST "Cumulus" Video Database Released (Partially) |
|---|
New 2010 additions listed below (and some TV network views listed above) come from a NIST Freedom of Information Act request thanks to James Gourley, Justin Keogh, and the International Center for 9/11 Studies -- who are uploading to YouTube channel IC911Studies, along with others. The first release of many in progress was the NIST Cumulus Video Database, which is not totally complete due to some copyright claims. It's 942GB of 6767 files in original uncompressed format or 83.9GB compressed (still high quality, same number of files). Download yourself using the torrents found at the wiki site 911datasets.org. Cumulus is release number 14, first in a list of many releases to come, totaling more than 4TB. Release 25 is 190GB. Release 27 is 430GB. Sorting all 36 releases is a work in progress. Terms of Use for Enclosed Records Released by National Institute of Standards and Technology under Freedom of Information Act To find the exact spot you linked from, press your BACK button. |
115. |
NIST 10: CNN North, Partial Street View Video |
|---|---|
|
WTCI-329-I-#20.wmv at 14:49 = While focusing on the NYPD helicopter the camera operator missed WTC 2 fall behind buildings in the foreground. The angle that captured the WTC 1 event only saw 2 seconds of debris falling in a glare. Some of the footage was aired on CNN, particularly people running. The camera operator didn't catch much of interest, but focused on the bewildered people mostly. Watch also at the NIST website. |
116. |
NIST 10: CNN's Tom Muccio YouTube |
|---|---|
|
The South Tower shot was televised. It's included in the YouTube link above. I named the camera angle for the reporter who narrated his footage 9/12 at 1:07 am-- footage which also included a closeup of a small numbered bracket belonging to a Boeing jet. |
117. |
NIST 10: East Partial YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Source: International Center for 9/11 Studies NIST FOIA, 911datasets.org release 10, WTCI-329-I-#23.wmv at 42:49 vrt -- after a long video containing a new WTC 7 collapse (partial). Both videos start after initiation, although WTC 1 burns in this shot for about 15 minutes after the WTC 2 collapse... which was totally missed. |
118. |
NIST 10: WNYW James Ford YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Found in WTCI-329-I-#12.wmv at vrt 24:25 (video also includes a rare audio of the 1st plane hitting, accidentally captured by WNYW's Dick Oliver). See also vrt 1:00:50 where James begins reporting (after Jim Ryan, the anchor in the studio, refers to the area as "Ground Zero"). Other interesting shots by James's cameraman include two wounded women who were struck by falling debris (it is assumed from the second plane exploding out of the north side of the South Tower). |
119. |
NIST 14: CBS-Net Dub2 11 (Unknown) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Also found in release 25 in mpeg-2 form, folder 42A0119 - G25D30. The camera operator and apparent friends speak Hebrew. Add info here - - - Add info here - - - Add info here - - - Add info here - - - Unknown amateur shot... |
120. |
NIST 14: Cindy Weil YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Extended length tape shows no visible shaking before the "collapse," as is the case in the Sauret footage (TV amateur above). This is clip 23 in the Cindy Weil folder from NIST. |
121. |
NIST 14: CNN Dub4 28 (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE: Videographer named "Robert Bery" with footage for download at the NIST WTC Repository on archive.org. Probably network camera footage, since four clips from before the collapses were included as a CNN folder in the NIST FOIA release 14 like "Kiederling" who did work for CNN. The shot was only made with overloaded audio rumbling like a train on gravel. A TV airing of this clip has not been found. Thanks to 911Crasting for uploading dozens of clips from the NIST FOIA, including the one linked above (and below). |
122. |
NIST 14: CNN Dub4 31 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Richard Lee Brennan, photographer, according to the NIST video repository on archive.org. This appears to be amateur footage shot from a tripod in the window of a home, the occupant of which happened to be watching CNN, the network that would air the WTC 2 demolition from this angle (see Richard Lee Brennan). This WTC 1 clip wasn't aired, as far as I know. |
123. |
NIST 14: FDNY Tape1 54 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
For some reason the camera is continuously zooming in and out, in and out, like a child was playing a game. This camera missed the 2nd plane impact, apparently. |
124. |
NIST 14: Matthew Shapoff YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Clip 10. Static camera, wide shot... and crooked. This of course could be an artistic statement. Compare to the NBC GE Building shot. That leaning view created a false impression the towers were unstable... which was abused. Note the footage is available in mpeg-2 in release 27, folder 42A0274 - G26D150. |
125. |
NIST 14: MSNBC OutOfRubble 18 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Excellent construction footage in these documentary clips. Hear the trusted narrator say the exterior load-bearing columns of the WTC could withstand the impact of a Boeing 707. You can also hear WTC construction manager Frank DeMartini say the same. The "MSNBC Investigates" episode "Out of the Rubble: The Aftermath of 9/11" originally aired 20 December, 2001 (according to IMDb, which has only the title and air date). NIST's version is incomplete, so the clips when joined aren't clear. |
126. |
NIST 14: NY1 6 Raw 52 YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
High quality video, despite the fact that WTC 7 blocks most of the tower. Click the YouTube link above to see it and 2 very close camera views from West Broadway: CNN Dub4 28 and Lucia Davis. The camera operator hasn't been identified, but NY1 crew in the area included John Schiumo (heard at 9:21 am say "here in Battery Park City" - nearby), Wiener Milien (named with a caption in HBO's "In Memoriam: New York City 9/11/01 - not nearby), Yogi Colon (seen narrating his collapse aftermath footage in the studio at 2:04 pm). UPDATE: This view is found in release 30, folder 42A0348 - G30D2, file name VTS_01_3.VOB. |
127. |
NIST 14: NY Firefighters Discovery 18 (partial) Watch |
|---|---|
|
Comes from "New York Firefighters: The Brotherhood of 9/11" (Discovery Channel, 2002 - sorry no full video link). Title should say "NY Firefighters Discovery 18 and 6", because 18 features only this new view... in slow motion from an earlier point. File 6 is in regular speed and continues later into the collapse of the core remnants (after the FireLine Video clip). |
128. |
NIST 14: Richard Peskin 25 (partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
UPDATE Dec. 2011: Download found at the NIST archive.org video repository. No known version exists with full collapse. Only the "spire" of tower core is seen. Amazing shot of the developing dust cloud. |
129. |
NIST 14: RptGndZero1_clip36 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
The 2002 ABC Program "Report from Ground Zero" aired Sept. 10, based on FDNY veteran Dennis Smith's best-selling book, Report from Ground Zero: The Story of the Rescue Efforts at the World Trade Center, Viking/Penguin, New York, 2002. The rare WTC 1 clip comes at about vrt 35:08. |
130. |
NIST 14: Tim Main & Mike Ballou YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Shot from the eastern bank of the East River just north of the Williamsburgh Bridge. Video also includes the South Tower's explosive, engineered collapse. A shockingly serene view. |
131. |
NIST 14: WCBS Dub1 32 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Appears in the folder "WCBS NIST Dub #1_Damas home video," however this is not the Damas home video, considering two things: 1. This angle makes up 2 of 32 clips from this folder not coming from the same camera, assuming the male voices are the same in both the WTC 2 and WTC 1 clips both from the NNE (and pretty close, unlike the 2 last clips in the folder). 2. The other 30 clips were shot from angles that actually aired on WCBS... and are much better quality. See above - Peter Damas. |
132. |
NIST 14: WNBC Dub4A 29 (partial) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Shot by WNBC camera operator Craig White starting at 10:28:21 a.m., according to the NIST website (wtcdata.nist.gov requires agreement to copyright terms [for cookie], then reclick this link if necessary). This angle is very similar to three others: APTN Below North 1 and 2, and one by WPIX. This one doesn't include the initiation, though. |
133. |
NIST 14: WNBC Dub4B 2 (partial) Watch |
|---|---|
|
This view is obscured not unlike the ABC Reporter Nina Pineda shot, from behind the Woolworth Building, north and east of the Trade Center. Thanks 911allcausticcamera for uploading, although by some people it might be considered a waste of time to watch. |
134. |
NIST 14: WNBC Dub9 09 (partial) no link available |
|---|---|
|
Another obscured shot, this only of the core remnant aka spire standing in smoke and dust... north and east of the Trade Center. A video link might be considered a waste of time... considering the wealth of video listed here. |
135. |
NIST 14: WNYW FOX5 SW YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Aired on TV at an unknown time. Listed in non-TV category despite the FOX5/WNYW logo. It's a rare view from southwest, similar to amateur Meridianmulti (partial)... and WCBS Chopper2. . Also see the newly available 2nd airplane impact video from this angle, listed as a non-televised amateur found as "WT Comp Reel." |
136. |
NIST 14: WPIX Dub3 73 (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Recorded on FDR Drive - the same camera that captured the second plane, "PAX-TV." Also found in Release 25, 42A0110 - G25D20, a DVD with extended footage (vrt 1:01:10. From this view the WTC 1 event is not much to see in comparison with the dozens of astonishing views above. |
137. |
NIST 20 - Crane, FBI #3 Watch |
|---|---|
|
FOIA release 20 folder 42A0061. Stable view, low 352x240 resolution (like others in Release 20). North Tower event begins at 1:32:48 in the original file. Named when the 2nd plane video was released by penttbom.com in a 2008 FOIA. This camera caught the 2nd plane impact and both collapses. I doubt the FBI learned anything from the video. |
138. |
NIST 20: FBI #10 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
Release 20, folder 42A0064. 352x240 resolution. North Tower event begins at 58:10 in the original file. This camera caught the 2nd plane impact and both collapses... but it was handheld. I doubt the FBI learned anything from the video. |
139. |
NIST 27 - FOX News North 1 Watch |
|---|---|
|
Release 27 is 427 GB, huge... although much is already available material. This upload comes from 911allcausticcamera, who credits folder 42A0213 - G26D73. Thanks. |
140. |
NIST 27 - FOX News North 2 (partial) Watch |
|---|---|
|
Found in release 27 folder 42A0216 - G26D77 at about frame 11200 in the DVD (VOB files joined, same as DVD). FOX News at an unknown time. What a giant banner blocking the view! Argh. |
141. |
NIST FOIA - NIST-FOIA-06-32-13-39-3 (partial) Watch |
|---|---|
|
New, FDNY video I think. Exclusively found at the NIST Review archive.org collection, Jan. 2012... only viewed 5 times since it was uploaded Nov. 2011. Not yet found in the above NIST FOIA releases from IC911Studies and 911datasets.org, after intensive searching. |
142. |
NIST WTC Repository 618_WTCI_468_I (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
New from the NIST WTC Repository at archive.org (May 2010, apparently), posted Nov. 2011 by 911allcausticcamera and titled as collapse 128. Smoke spoils the shot, like in other Brooklyn views. Initiation was missed, or edited (see 11:57 in original). WTC2 collapse was also missed. Low resolution and blue tone washout. Location by the Brooklyn Bridge is similar to the new 2011 Flight 175 shot by Howard Schickler. |
143. |
E.C. Norbro (NEW Sept. 2011) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Uploaded Sept. 1, 2011 by massasvassa and titled "9/11." Quoting from YouTube: I've kept these photos and video(s) in a box for the past decade. Not looking at them. Once or twice upon my return to Europe I showed them to a friend and to my mother, but that is all. [...] |
144. |
nyaroma (amateur) YouTube & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
The face in this video seriously conveys the horror of September 11. It's a shame some viewers will laugh at the person speaking Japanese (?) in red hair and lime green attire. |
145. |
Michael Parker - NW Jersey View metacafe |
|---|---|
![]() |
Steady medium shot with original audio of conversation mixed with added bass guitar sound for dramatic effect (I guess). Uploaded to metacafe.com Dec. 31, 2008 by videographer Last Wolf, titled "9/11 Remembered." The 2:24 length video has both "collapses," as seen from beside the Hudson River in New Jersey. The South Tower was perfectly lined up behind the North. |
146. |
passenger247 (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
YouTube user passenger247 has removed his video, but 911allcausticcamera ripped it and archived it. Considering the degraded quality and complete lack of audio, its only value seems to be another digit in this list. |
147. |
Peter_J_Rini (partial) Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
New 2011, uploaded to vimeo in memory of the 10th anniversary. Found by 911allcausticcamera. View nearby Rick Siegel, who - unlike this - recorded the whole event. . . . . . . |
148. |
Sceenz.com - "Unseen Footage" YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Copyright 2001 by sceenz.com. Titled "Unseen Footage from September 11th 2001. Ground Zero" as uploaded 9/19/2006 by YouTube user PA7. A pretty rare shot, but of poor quality, unfortunately. Another low res, glitchy version from CNYCLIVE.com is also online (link 2 above). |
149. |
Rick Siegel "911 Eyewitness Hoboken" YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
See www.911eyewitness.com and www.911raw.com, where the footage is unavailable. The audio is in question due to deep explosion sounds, as analyzed by Dave Shaw in the "911 Eyewitness Hoboken" DVD (YT link 2 above), or at www.mediumrecords.com/wtc/audio02.html (where you can download the Siegel clip). Quoting the audio engineer at mediumrecords.com: The dramatic nature of the blast sounds which occur in the 4 minutes prior to the collapse certainly raises some puzzling questions. Since other long stretches of unedited pre-collapse footage (with audio) from other angles has not yet been made public, it is not possible for us to hear if other recordings also caught these blasts. In other recordings from closer to the tower, though only short snippets are available, we don't see much of any indication that intense explosions have be registered [sic] by any people in the area. Certainly this webpage can help address the question of existing video with audio in the minutes before the first "collapse." See also this website's extensive 9/11 TV archive. Why is the video and especially audio record near the towers so slim during this time period? Or is it? Just because of the sensational nature of the destruction and otherwise uninteresting smoking towers? Please participate in the discussion on this bizarre audio debacle. (NOTICE my video links there are all dead since YouTube cancelled my [old] channel due to copyright claims... two by Naudet/Goldfish Pictures and one by "911 Eyewitness" for posting "9/11 Mysteries" by Sophia Shafquat, which used some of Rick's footage with different audio -- like many documentaries are known to do, but without his permission of course -- get the deleted video 911 Mysteries Pt 2 Secrets n Lies Exposed by Rick Siegel [flv] now, for more information). |
150. |
SY01 Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
Thanks to Dan Klein at bestshotfootage.com, who emailed me the video upon request. So far I haven't found it elsewhere. Side note: In 2008 the airplane video from this angle began to circulate. |
151. |
tag101joe - Queens View YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Steady wide shot. Uploaded to YouTube May 15, 2007 by tag101joe. Original title: "9/11 KNUCKLEBORO - FOOTAGE FROM OZONE PARK." Description: "9/11 SHORT CLIP HOW I SAW IT FROM THE ROOF WHERE I WORK , IN OZONE PARK , QUEENS , N.Y." |
152. |
"Thompson 25" by Annakin Slayd (NEW Sept. 2011) YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
Video includes 2nd plane hit (explosion only) and both collapses. The footage plays in the background of a thoughtful song by the videographer. See annakinslayd.com. The video begins with the text: On September 11th, 2001 Annakin Slayd and his roommate Elan Zafir were in lower Manhattan when the World Trade Center was attacked. As they walked the 13 blocks between their Thompson Street flat and the towers, they captured what they saw on a home video camera. This past summer Slayd walked that path once again, returning to Ground Zero for the first time. This also included both the WTC 2 and 1 collapses. |
153. |
TLC West - "Anatomy of the Collapse" (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
The 2002 TLC program World Trade Center - Anatomy Of The Collapse contains some rare stuff, but draws incorrect conclusions about the cause... even according to NIST. Truss failure wasn't the right answer. PBS-NOVA made the same error in "Why the Towers Fell" (2002). Lead investigator and spokesman for NIST, Shyam Sunder tells us in 2006 (PBS-NOVA's "Building on Ground Zero") that the "pancake theory" forwarded by ASCE lead man W. Eugene Corley was in fact - for want of a better word - bullsh!t. So, how long before the exterior-columns-bowed-in-and-snapped theory gets tossed? BECAUSE the initiation was inside the core. -- Download avi on terrorize.dk. |
154. |
"Tuesday Morning In September" YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
YouTube pre-release May 27, 2010. DVD was released 9/11/10. Videographer Jim Kosior has two YouTube channels: TuesdayMorningInSept and Supersynapsis. His movie "Tuesday Morning In September" consists of about 2 hours of lightly edited footage, including the second plane hit and both collapses. An effort is under way to professionally distribute the film.
|
155. |
Unknown East River View dead link |
|---|---|
![]() |
Found at mrfootage.com -- unknown. Smoke spoils the shot, unlike the South Tower video from this vantage point. |
156. |
Unknown NNE - "Antenna Tilting" YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
One example of this handheld wide shot found on YouTube was posted by VanDerLubbe. No info is offered, only a link to WeAreChange confronting Larry Silverstein. Note: a better quality shot from near this vantage point is above amateur Onno de Jong (alphabetically under J). |
157. |
Unknown NNE - killtheartist1 Watch |
|---|---|
![]() |
Steady wide shot (low resolution) found on YouTube in an "avant-garde video about the attacks" by killtheartist1. Not to be confused with the other Unknown NNE shot above. |
158. |
Unknown NNE - F.I.L.M: WTC Attacks 1 & 2 (partial) LiveLeak |
|---|---|
![]() |
Stock footage apparently no longer available at F.I.L.M. Archives, only LiveLeak in LOW res. The clip begins with footage from the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. Then both 9/11 "collapses" are included, but missing the initiations. |
159. |
Unknown N View - "Collapse 57" YouTube 1, 2, & 3 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Found by femr2 (see links 2 and 3 above) and by 911allcausticcamera, perhaps at terrorize.dk. Televised shot, unknown air date. .. .. .. .. .. .. |
160. |
Unknown N. View Collapse 127 (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
New Nov. 2011. Found by 911allcausticcamera and titled as collapse 127 -- source unknown. Low resolution with the tower obscured by trees and a person's head. . . . . . . . . . . . . |
161. |
Unknown N View - "Rare Collapse 6" YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Quality view archived by 911allcausticcamera. Camera location placed at 160 Varick St, according to researcher YougeneDebs (see comments at YouTube). South Tower event was missed, and 1 second of the N. Tower initiation was missed. Still, we get to see the zipper tear down the west side of the building faster than freefall. |
162. |
Unknown N Street View (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Very brief view archived by 911allcausticcamera, titled "Rare Collapse 23". Similar shot to "Zero" amateur, which can be seen below in much better quality. Thanks are due, nonetheless, for the archival images! This project owes a lot to 911allcausticcamera. |
163. |
Unknown NNW View, "Getty 2" YouTube |
|---|---|
![]() |
Found at Getty Images stock footage website, clip 98070855. Freaking pedestrians got in the way! They stop and turn as if they heard it, or the reactions behind them. Videographer unknown... but I know he was disappointed with the quality of his recording. |
164. |
Unknown SE View [from Window] YouTube & 2 |
|---|---|
![]() |
Found thanks to 911allcausticcamera, titled collapse 55. This and a couple more poor quality shots can be seen at mrfootage.com. The WTC smoke was blowing southeast, obscuring the view. - - - - - |
165. |
David Vanadia YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
From his website his video "My 9/11" is "an hour long video shot in the streets of New York City on September 11, 2001." Subtitles are a nice touch, especially with the numerous memorable quotes from witnesses in the film. My YouTube clip cut two thirds of the footage to compile some of the important parts, like airplane witnesses, an explosion near WTC Building 7, talk of the truck (or van) seen downtown with a picture of the towers getting hit by an airplane, that the cops apparently found (no photos of the van or truck have been made public, although police radio reported that between 6th and 7th on King Street, "it's a big truck with a mural painted of a, of a [sic] airplane diving into New York City and exploding." )... shots of burned papers in the street (despite the limited fire on upper floors of the towers).... Valuable lengthy video. |
166. |
Veoh Anonymous (partial) YouTube |
|---|---|
|
High quality clips including WTC 7. Xenomorph911WTC uploaded this with the title "9/11: Anonymous new release of 3 WTC collapse videos," on December 06, 2008... a month and a week after the videos (not including the South Tower clip) appeared on veoh.com. From Xeno's more info (and similarly at 911blogger.com), we read: An anonymous source has allowed the release of high quality DVD footage of all 3 WTC collapses. The North & South Tower & building 7. The photographer wishes to remain anonymous and audio has not been given permission for public release, but you can download the files here without sound, in high quality DVD format cut from the source video at the following links. [edit: megaupload.com has been shut down, so no downloads.] Thanks, Xeno. |
167. |
James Ronald Whitney YouTube 1 & 2 |
|---|---|
|
As seen in his emotional film "Telling Nicholas." After the filmmaker "was forced from his home by the debris cloud that rose from the ash of the falling towers, he contacted the family of a missing woman he saw on a flier. She was the mother of 7-year-old Nicholas. Whitney tells the powerful story of Nicholas, whose father waited 10 days before telling him that his mother is dead." Full, high quality version of the footage (also WTC 2) isn't available, yet. |
168. |
ZERO: An Investigation of 9/11 YouTube |
|---|---|
|
The issue raised during the clip in question is about freefall speed during the "collapses." Concerning WTC Building 7, it's an open-and-shut case! (see the911forum, for example) Regarding the towers, the point remains valid. If you've seen the above higher quality videos, you know the explosions tore down the side of the building faster than freefall. |
Fair Use Notice: This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Users may make such material available in an effort to advance awareness and understanding of issues relating to civil rights, economics, individual rights, international affairs, liberty, science and technology, etc. We believe this constitutes a "fair use" of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information please visit: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml .